If you grew up in the 1950s, you’re well aware that a lost tooth could bring in anywhere from a nickel to a dime. We were so excited when we got a loose tooth that we would wiggle it around, hoping it would pop out. Alas, times have changed, and so has the Tooth Fairy’s fee. According to the 2026 Original Tooth Fairy Poll, there’s never been a better time to lose your baby teeth. Today, the Tooth Fairy fetches an average of $5.84 for a single tooth. If it’s your first lost tooth, you’re getting a premium rate: $7.17 for that one-time event. Yes, the Tooth Fairy knows just how special that milestone is in a kid’s life. The first Original Tooth Fair Poll took place in 1998, and at that time the Tooth Fairy payout averaged $1.30 per tooth. Over the years, that rate has increased by an incredible 349% to this year’s nearly $6 average. The value of a lost tooth tends to increase every year, but over the past few years that hasn’t been the case. In 2023, the value of a lost baby tooth began a 2-year decline that finally ended with this year’s poll. After a couple of thrifty years, the Tooth Fairy decided it was time to give kids a well-deserved raise. Believe it or not, the Tooth Fairy is pretty financially savvy and takes regional costs of living into consideration. In the pricier Northeast, the Tooth Fairy pays higher amounts than in the rest of the country, while the Midwestern Tooth Fairy has more affordable rates — though they are moving up fast and had the biggest year-over-year jump. To see what your region pays on average, check out the map below.
Strangely enough, the Tooth Fairy follows the stock market. With few exceptions, the value of baby teeth has mirrored the S&P 500 and the economy in general. If there’s any good news, it’s that the average child has only 20 baby teeth (which are replaced by 32 permanent teeth). At roughly $6 per tooth, you’re only going to be out around $120. It could be worse……..you could be one of those never-empty-nesters whose kid lives with them until they’re 42. Talk about expensive!





