Muttontown — a small village on Long Island — has long been considered a hidden gem of New York, and is now ranked the wealthiest small town in the state. With a population of less than 3,500, the town was deemed the most prosperous small town in a recent analysis. On average, Muttontown residents have a median household income of $247,589 and properties worth around $2.2 million. Despite the tiny town earning the top rank in wealth, it had the lowest livability score, with a rating of 56. Livability scores are drawn from various factors, including amenities, cost of living, crime rates, education, etc. Among the tiny population are big-name celebrities like Grammy Award-winning artist Alicia Keys. The affluent neighborhood is about 31 miles east of Manhattan. One of the town’s more exclusive offerings is the Muttontown Club, a country club with golf, fitness areas, and pools, all centered around the pristine manor.
![]() |
| Alicia Keys' House |




